ForgotPassword?
Sign Up
Search this Topic:
Forum Jump
Posts: 11308
Feb 22 08 11:27 AM
Posts: 3588
Feb 22 08 1:04 PM
Registered Member
Feb 27 08 9:57 AM
Feb 27 08 11:35 AM
Feb 27 08 12:19 PM
Feb 27 08 1:12 PM
mcmaenza wrote: Droid, I totally agree. Of the guys, David A. is clearly the best. If he keeps pulling out stellar performances week after week, he should clearly sail to the top of the heap. As for the other five guys to make the top 12, I'm looking for a little variety to entertain me until they're picked off one-by-one. I think Danny Noriega just might make it to the top 12 just on the sheer "what will he do next?" factor. He's clearly this year's Sanjaya.
David Noriega is this years Sanjaya, without Sanjaya's vocal talent. I can see Noriega sticking a round for a few weeks, just because I think the teenie-bopper girls will vote for him. But David A. is just as appealing as Noriega and is also phenomenally talented. If it were up to me, he'd be gone this Thursday, along with Jason Yeager. David Cook is probably the second best guy. I forget the Aussie's name, but he doesn't impress me either.
Feb 27 08 1:51 PM
Posts: 6646
Feb 27 08 2:49 PM
Feb 27 08 2:51 PM
Feb 27 08 3:01 PM
Feb 27 08 3:40 PM
Feb 27 08 3:52 PM
Feb 27 08 4:14 PM
Feb 27 08 10:53 PM
Posts: 7726
Feb 27 08 11:03 PM
Feb 28 08 8:28 AM
Feb 28 08 11:40 AM
Feb 28 08 1:26 PM
Feb 28 08 5:26 PM
mcmaenza wrote: Droid, I think Amanda brings some variety. Idol isn't just about voice for me - it is attitude and presentation as well. She's something different and would work well with the right song vibes. Plus she's not one of the cookie cutter blondes. I would go see Amanda perform in a local bar if I had a chance. I'm sure it would be an entertaining show and keep me interested. This is why I put her at 6th - I'd like to see her in the top 12. Granted, I'm not voting at this stage - I never vote until it gets down to the final four or so because otherwise what's the point. It's money wasted. Most likely America won't agree with me and Amanda could go tonight or next week. I'm hoping not.
Obviously, you can watch Idol for whatever reasons you want to. But the bottom line is, it IS a singing competition an the winner gets a recording contract. To SING. The noise my cat makes when I accidently step on her tail is more pleasant than the vocals Amanda laid down last night!
Feb 28 08 8:41 PM
Share This