While it looks like the New 52 is a success for DC, it is a failure for me.  I tried out every first wave New 52 title, and most of the 2nd/3rd wave titles.  I've cut my subscriptions down to:

    • Action Comics

    • All-Star Western (Shaky ground)
    • Animal Man

    • Batman

    • Batman and Robin

    • Batman, Incorporated

    • Batman: The Dark Knight (Shaky ground)

    • Catwoman (Shaky ground)

    • Demon Knights (Shaky ground)

    • Detective Comics

    • Dial H (Too new to judge)

    • Earth Two (Too new to judge)

    • Frankenstein, Agent of Shade (Shaky ground)

    • I, Vampire  

    • Justice League Dark  (Shaky ground)

    • Legion Lost (Shaky ground)

    • Legion of Superheroes

    • Nightwing

    • Phantom Stranger (I'll give it a try)

    • Stormwatch
    • Swamp Thing  

      • Sword of Sorcery (I'll give it a try)

      • Talon (I'll give it a try)

      • Worlds’ Finest (Too new to judge)


    DC Mini-Series/Specials:

    • The Shade

    • Night Force



    Overall, I'm really dissapointed by the more super-hero oriented books, although I think most of the Batman line is still pretty good.  I still like Paul Levitz's Legion of Super Heroes (I'm buying Legion Lost purely out of LSH loyalty).  I can't belive I dropped Superman ... a title I've been buying for, well, decades!  I'll stick with Grant Morrison's Action Comics a while longer, as long as I don't get too many more stories like "President Superman."

    Animal Man and Swamp Thing are excellent.  I hope All-Star Western reverts back to a western again, instead of trying to insert Jonah Hex into the Batman mythos. 

    My first comic books: Superboy and the Legion of Super Heroes #202 and Kamandi, the Last Boy on Earth #23.  What a great way to start!