The judge also gave a great deal of weight to Lee's claim that he created the basic concepts, and as a result was from the start setting the whole process in motion.
On page five of her ruling the judge says Marvel's motion, "stands of falls on his (Lee's) testimony."
There was no substantive way of showing who came up with the core concepts before they were expanded, so there was no hard evidence to contradict Lee's version of events.
It's one judges decision. Toberoff says he will appeal, as Disney would have done if the decision had gone against them.


Last Edited By: alexarkadin Jul 28 11 10:12 PM. Edited 1 times.