Gormuu wrote:
riftt wrote:
-No Omnibuses of already OHC'd material please - this is a total waste of omnibus slots


Well, I can relate to your concerns, but I don't see it as a total waste. I mean, now that the Omniboo feature sewn binding, I prefer the Punisher by Garth Ennis Omnibus over the corresponding glued OHCs.

And since the Omnibus and all the OHCs of that material sold through, the market apparently thought an Omnibus wasn't a total waste of a slot.

Stuff that's been previously seen in OHC that I would like to see in Omnibus editions include Annihilation, Punisher MAX and Ultimate stuff.
Respectfully disagree.  The Ennis Punisher Omnibus collected two tpb's (Streets of Laredo and Confederacy of Dunces) that had NOT been OHC'd, and were long out of print and going for $$$ on ebay. 

An omnibus of Annihilation or Punisher Max, even with sewn binding, is NOT going to be easier to read than the much slimmer, more manageable OHC's (not to mention it's never a given that the omnibus will be sewn anyway). 

I dunno, I think people who buy floppies shouldnt have a say in the matter.  You have floppies - you can go out and buy anything until your heart's content.  Me, I have to wait for trades, and there is a wealth of great Marvel books out there that have never seen the light of day in collected form of any kind.  Seeing something that has not only already been collected, but collected in such a nice prestige format as OHC get doubled dipped into an omnibus over a good group of material that has never been collected just gets my blood boiling a little.