Monsty wrote:
I really feel the X-Men are a broken franchise.

I liked the first three OHC's of Astonishing, but anything else from this group just seems so tired.

Not even Brubaker can revive this team.

I thought Fraction was on the right track in X-Men 500 by moving them to SF and actually making them respected heroes.

That turned sour pretty quickly.

Now, they are hated again (ughh!!!), living on an island in SF Bay, and dealing with Magneto. Oh boy....

Save your dough, Ray.


Have to disagree, the X titles from Supernovas and Rise/Fall thru Messiah Complex to now are as good as they ahve been this decade. Probably better than anything since the mid 90's