mcmaenza, I get the fact that you don't like David A. or his current genre, but the indisputable fact is that he's got the best voice of any contestant this season and arguably any season of American Idol. And he's so young, that he will no doubt reinvent himself many times before his career is over. And while your near-term predictions for him may or may not come true, his voice is just way too good for him to be a complete failure. He's going to be around and be successful for many, many years.

Which is not to take anything away from David C. He's incredibly talented as well and will also no doubt have a very successful career. In fact, this is the first season that I can remember where I don't think it's possible to make a wrong choice. Both contestants are equally deserving of winning. If David C. wins, I'd have no problem with that. If David A. wins, I'd have no problem with that, either.