Totally agree, mcmaenza. David Cook vs Syesha would have been interesting. David A in the finals = YAWN! I'm tuning in to see how David Cook handles the finale musically and that's about it. The finales are so anticlimactic because both performers get big recording deals no matter who wins or loses. The only big suspenseful question now is if a CD by any of the finalists would actually appeal to the music-buying public and we won't know that for quite a while.