comix750 wrote:
What I think:
Michael Johns should've won- finally they had a classic rocker on the show, my fave genre, and so what if he wasn't that original? The guy had a great voice
Syesha usually sux balls but last night she was the best
David Archuleta for me is just meh but i know he's super popular
David Cook is 2nd best overall
Jason Castro to me is (now that Mike left) probably the best one
Brooke is ultra-sexy but sucks at singing-she should've gone
Carly- she was always ok for me- not the best, not the worst

my 2 cents...

Not trying to dis you or pick a fight, just want to illustrate how differently people view the contestants.


No way Michael Johns should have won. He was no rocker, merely a rocker wannabe. A guy with an average voice, at best, hoping to make it on his looks and Aussie accent. There's a reason that he spent most of his adult life trying to make it in the music industry and failed.

Syesha was shaky at first but has improved nearly every week. She's had one of the top 2 or 3 performances for the last 6 weeks. only 20 years old and very underrated.

David A. has the best vocal talent in the competition, bar none. His problem is that he's too young to know what to do with it. He'll be a star in a few years.

David C. is the best competitor on the show this season and has been since the top 24 started. With few exceptions has had the best performance on a weekly basis.

Jason Castro. Dear God, why is this hack still here? He had no business making the top 24, let alone the top 5. Tiny Tim reincarnated.

Brooke White is extremely talented musically. Has a great voice and could surprise wveryone with an upset victory, although I don't think that will happen. Guaranteed future star

Carly Hennessey-Smithson. There was a reason that she flopped even after a major record label dumped over $2 million dollars promoting her. She's not that good. Powerful voice that tends to be shrill instead of melodious.