mcmaenza wrote:
Guys, I agree - David Cook is best served going out around 4th or 3rd. That way he gets a better chance to make a debut album that has more of his input to it.

I didn't notice Brook trembling but perhaps the competition is taking its toll on her. I am sure missing her sister's wedding last weekend could not have been easy for it. As for her losing the piano, I don't know - it seems she feels better singing when she has that crutch. When she just sits or stands and sings, well... she seems to have a harder time. Like Droid, I once had her locked for top three but I am thinking she could easily go sooner than that.

The thing about Brooke and her piano is that when it works, it's magical. When it doesn't work, is disasterous. No in between.


Brooke is talented enough to make the top three as long as she doesn't hang herself with her own rope. She can't afford too many more nights like last night. She'd be better off playing it safe.