I pretty much disagree with your entire post.


That's OK, droid. I expected that you would! We watch Idol with different ears and different expectations. Personally, I favor artists who choose to perform music that I personally enjoy as well as the overall performance...that is, how much they managed to entertain me. Just rating voices and vocal potential and voting people through on that seems very boring to me. I like to look at the overall package and frequently that means people that don't have the best technical voices.