I agree with most of your assessments, Kam. I agree that Brooke should have done this solo. Still a pretty solid effort by her, though. "Let It Be" was awesome, I doubt she'll top that performance.

I thought that from Michael Johns forward the performances were all very good, except for David Archuleta. He was okay, but just.. I don't know...bad song choice, I think. Carly was great! Totally disagreed with the judges there as well. That song should be sung with intensity, and Carly did great.

I'm not a big country fan, but still, Kristy Lee did one of my favorite songs "God Bless the U.S.A" and she nailed it! I thought she did very well with that.

David Cook was by FAR the best, though. Wow.. I was very impressed with his performance. I agree, he's headed for stardom even if he doesn't win this season.

Same bottom three for me, Ramiele, Chikezie and David A. I think Ramiele will be gone next.