LOL! I liked your righteous indignation regarding my Season 5 McFever opinions!

Well, we're just going to have to agree to disagree on a lot of Idol stuff. Obviously, different things float our respective boats.

And David C can play and sing as good if not better than Brooke. My main point with the instruments, though, is that it will now start attracting more diverse talents to the competition in future seasons and I think we will start to see contestants that are a lot more versatile.