I can't believe no one has commented that Carly only did Aerosmith doing the Beatles.


And Syesha only did Earth Wind and Fire doing The Beatles and David A only did Stevie Wonder doing The Beatles. Idol contestants have been adapting well established arrangements of cover versions to popular songs for years. For some, it is the only way to succeed when they have to pick from a group of songs that doesn't suit their personal style. Nothing wrong with that as I see it.