You guys were good with nailing the bottom 3, but did you see THAT coming tonight? (I didn't, but I'm not surprised.) I don't care what anyone says--you can't tell me that Hernandez being 'found out' as a gay stripper/lap dancer didn't play a part of that...

Honestly--I'm not prejudiced against gays, and everyone has to make a living. But after that came out about him, he lost his whole "squeaky clean I wanna be an American Idol" image and just seemed phony to me, for some reason.

Anyway--I no longer have a 90% certainty about the young David A anymore, I'm leaning more towards David Cook...