OK, the chicks this week...

Good:

Brooke - tender, stripped down "Love is a Battlefield" surprisingly worked for me
Carly - Knock out version of the Cyndi Lauper song! Not sure why Simon had a problem with it other than he just didn't like the song
Syesha - Good, although extremely predictable, Whitney Houston imitation

OK:

Amanda - Much, much better this week with a Joan Jett song that played to her strengths instead of exposed her weaknesses
Kady - I think it's insane for a female to take on Freddie Mercury, but she did an OK job with it and it was a pretty gutsy choice
Ramiele - Totally phoned in the Phil Collins song, but no pressure on her at all this week as she knows she's going to the final 12

Bad:

Asiah - Her voice was NOT up to the Whitney Houston song and I thought it really exposed her limitations...also, it was quite boring
Kristy Lee - Bad choice to try a Steve Perry vocal...it really made her sound average and forgettable