NewWorld, I COULDN'T AGREE MORE. I thought the exact same thing last night about that kid & "Melinda Doolittle syndrome". He's a nice guy but Lord I hope he stops beaming with surprise soon.

The Leif Garrett clone had the most unoriginal version of a song last night--I hope Martin is wrong and this guy doesn't become the new Sanjaya; too much other good talent up there.

The guy who sang 'Moon River', very nice and just won't last. He almost seems too old up there...

Martin, agree about Chickuzzi...he showed way too much attitude, too early on. (But man, Simon still surprises me with his roughness)